language: en kae3g ← back to index
(unlisted) — This essay is not shown on the main index but remains accessible via direct link

kae3g 9988: The New Ancient Cities — 2025 Geopolitical Cartography

Timestamp: 12025-10-06–rhizome-valley
Series: Technical Writings (9999 → 0000)
Category: Geopolitics, Historical Patterns, Strategic Analysis
Reading Time: 20 minutes

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." — George Santayana

"Under heaven all is chaos; the situation is excellent." — Attributed to Mao Zedong (possibly apocryphal, but instructive)

"The more things change, the more they stay the same." — Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr

Warning: This essay contains opinionated analysis of current conflicts. It seeks historical patterns, not political advocacy. Read with discernment.

For Guardian Garden PBC: Understanding empire's decline helps us build what comes after.

Introduction: The Eternal Return of Geopolitical Archetypes

History doesn't repeat, but it rhymes—sometimes in perfect iambic pentameter.

The cities and conflicts of 2025 mirror ancient patterns with uncanny precision. Not because history is cyclical, but because human nature, geography, and power dynamics follow predictable forms. Maritime powers challenge land powers. Trading cities become wealthy and vulnerable. Imperial overreach precedes collapse. Regional powers compete for legitimacy.

The thesis: Every major city in 2025 can be mapped onto an ancient archetype. Understanding these patterns helps us navigate the chaos and build resilient communities in the spaces between empires.

The method: Rich Hickey teaches us to find the simple essence beneath complex surfaces. Let's strip away modern terminology and see the ancient patterns.

Part I: The Three Theaters of Conflict

Theater One: Ukraine — The Endless Steppe War

Historical Pattern: The Ukrainian plains have been contested for millennia. Scythians, Sarmatians, Goths, Huns, Khazars, Mongols, Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, Russian Empire, Soviet Union—the list is long because the pattern is eternal.

Why: The Ukrainian breadbasket is the most productive agricultural land in Europe, a natural invasion route between East and West, and whoever controls it controls food security for the continent.

The Ancient War This Resembles: The Greco-Persian Wars (499-449 BCE), but reversed.

Key Insight: Like the Persian Wars, this isn't about Ukraine itself—it's about whether western liberal democracy or eastern autocracy dominates the Eurasian landmass. The grain fields of Ukraine are the 21st century's Thermopylae.

Theater Two: Gaza and Iran — The Levantine Perpetual War

Historical Pattern: The Eastern Mediterranean has been a war zone since cities first emerged. Egypt vs. Hittites, Assyria vs. everyone, Babylon vs. Judah, Persia vs. Greece, Rome vs. Parthia, Byzantium vs. Sassanids, Crusaders vs. Saracens, Ottomans vs. everyone.

Why: The Levant is the land bridge between Africa, Asia, and Europe. Whoever controls it controls trade routes. It's also saturated with religious significance for Judaism, Christianity, and Islam—making compromise nearly impossible.

The Ancient War This Resembles: The Punic Wars (264-146 BCE), but theological.

Key Insight: Rome destroyed Carthage so thoroughly that we know their history only through Roman sources. This is the terror that drives Israeli strategy—survival through total victory. But Rome fell too, exhausted by perpetual war. Both sides fear becoming Carthage; both risk becoming late Rome.

Theater Three: United States — The Republic's Crisis

Historical Pattern: Republics collapse when internal factions value victory over their opponents more than the survival of the republic itself. See: Athens (Peloponnesian War), Rome (Social Wars → Civil Wars), Weimar Germany, modern Venezuela.

Why: The United States has geographic immunity (oceans, weak neighbors) but is destroying itself from within. Urban/rural divide, coastal/interior, knowledge economy/industrial decay, demographic change, information warfare, institutional delegitimization.

The Ancient Crisis This Resembles: The Roman Republic, 133-27 BCE (from the Gracchi to Augustus).

Key Insight: The Roman Republic didn't fall to external invasion—it committed suicide. The institutions remained; the spirit died. We're past the Rubicon. The question isn't "if" the republic ends, but "what comes after"—Augustus (stable autocracy) or continued civil war?

Part II: The New Ancient Cities — A Provocative Mapping

The New Constantinople: Istanbul (Literally)

Why it's still Constantinople:

2025 Status: Turkey is the kingmaker in Ukraine (drone supplies), the negotiator in grain deals, the NATO member that won't quite commit, the Muslim power that maintains ties with Israel while supporting Palestinians. Just like Byzantine emperors playing diplomacy as an art form.

The Pattern: Empires fall, but strategic geography remains. Istanbul will matter in 2125.

The New Rome: Washington D.C.

Why it's Rome (and not New York or Los Angeles):

2025 Status: Late Imperial Rome, somewhere between Marcus Aurelius (philosopher emperor, system still works) and Diocletian (strongman reforms, empire splits). The Rubicon is crossed; we're in the crisis of the third century, waiting for Constantine or the final collapse.

The Question: Will America find its Constantine (strongman who stabilizes) or continue fragmenting until there's an Augustus (founder of stable autocracy) or just... fall?

The New Athens: San Francisco/Bay Area

Why it's Athens:

2025 Status: Post-Peloponnesian War Athens—still culturally influential, politically irrelevant, economically hollowed out. The tech industry is what Athenian philosophy became: influential but impotent.

The New Sparta: Moscow

Why it's Sparta:

2025 Status: Sparta at war with Athens (Moscow vs. Western liberalism), knowing it will win battles but lose the cultural war. Sparta won the Peloponnesian War and gained... nothing. Athens lost and gained immortality. Russia may "win" in Ukraine and still collapse from internal contradictions.

The New Carthage: Gaza (and Palestinian Diaspora)

Why it's Carthage:

2025 Status: Gaza is the city that refuses to die. Rome destroyed Carthage utterly in 146 BCE—salted the earth, sold survivors into slavery, erased it from maps. It came back anyway. Gaza will too, because desperation breeds resilience.

The Warning: Rome destroyed Carthage and gained nothing but guilt and eventual barbarian invasion. Total victory is pyrrhic.

The New Troy: Kyiv

Why it's Troy:

2025 Status: Year 3 of a 10-year siege. Troy fell, but Aeneas escaped to found Rome. Kyiv may fall, but Ukrainian resistance will seed something new. Or Kyiv holds, and becomes the story that ends Russian imperialism.

The Twist: The Iliad isn't about whether Troy falls—it's about honor, rage, and the cost of war. Same with Ukraine.

The New Alexandria: Dubai

Why it's Alexandria:

2025 Status: Peak Alexandria—before Caesar and Cleopatra, before Rome annexes it, before the library burns. Enjoy it while it lasts.

The New Babylon: Beijing

Why it's Babylon:

2025 Status: Peak Babylonian power, not yet conquered by Persia (the US) or Alexander (whatever comes after). But empires always fall. Always.

The Pattern: Babylon fell to Cyrus the Great because its own people opened the gates. China's weakness isn't military—it's internal legitimacy. The gates will open from within.

The New Thebes: Tehran

Why it's Thebes:

2025 Status: Thebes after Leuctra—has proven it can win, not yet destroyed by Alexander. The destruction may be coming (Israel's nuclear calculus), or Iran may survive to see its enemies fall first.

The New Memphis: Cairo

Why it's Memphis:

2025 Status: Museum city. Influential in culture (Al-Azhar still certifies Islamic legitimacy), irrelevant in power politics. Egypt is no longer Egyptian—it's a client state managing poverty while regional players (Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Israel) make decisions.

The New Persepolis: Riyadh

Why it's Persepolis:

2025 Status: Peak Persepolis. The wealth is staggering, the projects audacious. But Alexander is coming—his name is "renewable energy transition." When oil dies, the desert reclaims the palaces.

The New Jerusalem: Jerusalem (Actually)

Why it's still Jerusalem:

2025 Status: Exactly what it's always been—the city where the world ends or begins, depending on your scripture. Every empire that touches it is cursed; every empire that ignores it is judged.

The Warning: Jerusalem destroyed Rome (the cost of the Jewish Wars bankrupted the empire). It destroyed Crusader kingdoms. It will destroy whoever "wins" it next. Some cities cannot be conquered—only endured.

Part III: The American Cities in Civil War Context

The New Carthage (American Edition): California (Specifically Los Angeles + Bay Area)

Why it's Carthage:

2025 Status: Carthage before the Third Punic War—wealthy, disarmed, trusting in treaties that won't save it.

The New Athens (American Edition): New York City

Why it's Athens:

2025 Status: Post-Pericles Athens—still rich, still influential, but the Peloponnesian War (American polarization) is destroying it from within.

The New Sparta (American Edition): Texas + Florida Coalition

Why it's Sparta:

2025 Status: Sparta preparing for war with Athens, confident in military superiority, ignorant of economic/cultural vulnerabilities.

The New Rome (American Edition): Washington D.C. (Redux)

Already covered above, but worth emphasizing:

2025 Status: Rome during Marius and Sulla—about to be fought over, will never be the same after.

Part IV: The Pattern of Decline and What Comes After

The Simple Pattern (Rich Hickey's Wisdom Applied)

Strip away complexity, find the essence:

Phase 1: Hegemonic Peace (Pax Romana, Pax Britannica, Pax Americana)

Phase 2: Overreach (Rome in Germania, Britain in Afghanistan, US in Iraq/Afghanistan)

Phase 3: Internal Division (Rome's civil wars, Britain's class wars, America's culture wars)

Phase 4: Fragmentation (Western/Eastern Rome, British Commonwealth, American ???)

Phase 5: Dark Ages or Renaissance? (This is the choice)

We are in Phase 3, approaching Phase 4.

The question for Guardian Garden communities: How do we prepare for Phase 5?

The Ecological Wisdom (Helen Atthowe Applied)

Helen Atthowe teaches: Don't till the soil; observe the patterns; work with nature.

Applied to geopolitics:

Don't till the soil:

Observe the patterns:

Work with nature:

The Guardian Garden Strategy:

Part V: Predictions and Preparations (2025-2050)

Predictions (Based on Pattern Recognition, Not Prophecy)

Ukraine War (New Greco-Persian Wars):

Gaza/Iran War (New Punic Wars):

American Crisis (New Roman Civil Wars):

Global Order:

Preparations (For Guardian Garden Communities)

Assume:

Build:

Connect:

Preserve:

Conclusion: After Empire, the Garden

From the Tao Te Ching (Stephen Mitchell): *"The empire is a sacred vessel, and must not be tampered with. Those who tamper with it, ruin it. Those who seize it, lose it."*

From the Gospel (Stephen Mitchell): *"Do not store up treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy. But store up treasures in heaven— which is to say, in the eternal patterns, in the garden, in community."*

From Rich Hickey: *"Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication. Complex systems fail in complex ways. Simple systems endure."*

From Helen Atthowe: *"The soil remembers everything. Empires rise and fall, but the garden endures. Work with nature, not against it."*

The Final Mapping

Constantinople endures because geography is destiny. Rome falls because empires always fall. Athens lives forever in ideas, dies in politics. Sparta wins battles and loses history. Carthage is destroyed and rises as an idea. Troy falls and seeds new empires. Babylon declines because autocracy is fragile. Jerusalem remains because some cities are eternal wounds. Alexandria drowns in luxury and sand. Thebes fights bravely and dies anyway.

The pattern is clear. The choice is ours.

We can cling to empires as they fall (Rome's citizens cheering in the Colosseum while Goths approached).

Or we can build gardens in the ruins (Irish monks copying manuscripts in 600 CE, preserving knowledge for the Renaissance 800 years later).

Guardian Garden chooses the latter.

Not because we're naive about power. Not because we're ignorant of history.

But because we've read history carefully enough to know: **Empires fall. Gardens endure. Simple systems survive. Communities persist. Knowledge returns. Life finds a way.**

Appendix: The Questions This Essay Raises

For the reader to contemplate:

  1. If your city is the new [ancient city], what does that mean for your strategy?
  2. Which phase of decline is your nation in?
  3. What are you preserving for the future?
  4. When empire falls, will your community survive?
  5. Are you building gardens or defending palaces?

The most important question: What would you do differently if you knew—truly knew—that this empire will fall within your lifetime?

This essay is dedicated to:

Released to Public Domain. No copyright, no ownership, just pattern recognition and humble preparation.

For Guardian Garden PBC and all who prepare for what comes after empire.

"In the space between the fall of one empire and the rise of the next, gardens grow." 🌱

Timestamp: 12025-10-06--rhizome-valley
Iteration: 12 of 2000
Remaining: 1988

Previous: 9989: The Guardian Garden Guide
Next: 9987 (to be written)

Copyright © 2025 kae3g | Dual-licensed under Apache-2.0 / MIT
Competitive technology in service of clarity and beauty

View Hidden Docs Index | Return to Main Index

← back to index